Main Content

Identifying Popular, Trade and Scholarly Journal Articles

Printer-friendly version (PDF/30KB)

Often your professor will suggest that you use scholarly* or peer-reviewed** journal articles for your research project. It is not always easy to discern the difference between the three major article types, scholarly, trade and popular. The chart below has been designed to assist, but please consult your professor or a librarian if you are unsure about identifying a particular article in this manner.

 

CRITERIA SCHOLARLY* TRADE POPULAR
Authors Written by authorities/experts Written by professionals in the field, or freelancers Written by journalists, freelancers, or guest contributors
Editors Editors require that articles be reviewed by peers No peer-review process No peer-review process
Article Length Lengthier articles (5–20+ pages) Short to medium-length articles (1–20 pages) Short articles or columns (1–10 pages)
Publication Frequency Published 2–4 times per year Published weekly or monthly Published daily (newspapers), weekly or monthly
Appearance Plain covers, matte paper, few illustrations & few ads, but many tables, figures, charts, graphs Flashy covers, glossy paper, eye-catching illustrations & ads, some photos, cartoons, sidebars Flashy covers, glossy paper, eye-catching illustrations & ads, photos, cartoons, sidebars, sometimes newspapers
Purpose Inform, report, or make available original research to scholars and researchers Examine problems or concerns in a particular profession or industry for practitioners Entertain or persuade readers with general interest topics, or to sell products; usually not subject-specific
Tone & Language Serious, academic, subject-specific language Educated, subject-specific language Entertaining or news-oriented, simple language
References Sources are cited: bibliography, references, and/or footnotes used Sources are usually not cited Sources are rarely cited: no bibliographies or footnotes
Access • Through subscribing academic libraries
• Indexed only in subject-specific databases such as Criminal Justice Abstracts
• Usually sent to office of subscribing practitioners
• Indexing is scattered, but fullest coverage is through business indexes such as Business Source Premier
• Newsstands or to homes of resident subscribers
• Indexed in general-purpose databases such as Academic Search Premier
Examples: Business: Quarterly Review of Economics & Business
Psychology: Journal of Family Psychology
Criminal Justice: Justice Quarterly
Theology: Catholic Historical Review
Nursing: Critical Care Nursing
Quarterly
General Interest: not applicable
Business: Advertising Age
Psychology: APA Review
Criminal Justice: Police Chief
Theology: Clergy Review
Nursing: Nursing Times
General Interest: not applicable
Business: Business Week
Psychology: Parents
Criminal Justice: Corrections Today
Theology: Christianity Today
Nursing: Prevention
General Interest: Newsweek, Sports Illustrated, People, National Enquirer, Good Housekeeping, etc.

 

* Scholarly journal items:  Not everything published in scholarly journals is appropriate for research use. For example, book reviews, editorial (opinion) pieces, short news items etc. do not count as "scholarly articles". If you are unsure about using the information you've found, be sure to check with a librarian or your professor.

** Peer-review:  This is the process requiring that each article submitted for publication be judged by an independent panel of experts (scholarly or scientific peers). Articles not approved by a majority of these peers are not accepted for publication by the journal.